Free for 30 days: NaliSuite cloud ERP for your business
Client Login
ZAR
Client LoginRegister
Business Software

Accounting Software vs Spreadsheets in South Africa

4 min read Hostnali team

Accounting software dashboard compared with a spreadsheet for businesses in South Africa

Picture two print shops in Pretoria. Same size, same customers, same staff of six. One keeps its books in a shared Excel workbook; the other uses accounting software. Follow both through a month and the difference between the tools becomes very concrete.

Monday: a big order arrives

The spreadsheet shop quotes in Word, converts the quote to an invoice in a template and then adds the sale to the “Sales” tab. VAT at 15% is calculated by a formula someone set up two years ago.

The software shop sends a quotation, the customer accepts it online and it turns into an invoice with VAT on each line. The sale is posted to the ledger the moment the invoice is issued.

Wednesday: load-shedding

The spreadsheet shop’s workbook lives on the bookkeeper’s laptop. When the power goes, so does access to the books, and an unsaved hour of entries is lost.

The software shop’s books are in the cloud. Staff carry on from a phone on mobile data, and nothing depends on one machine staying charged.

Friday: money comes in

Customers pay by EFT and card. The spreadsheet shop downloads the bank statement, scrolls through it and types “paid” next to invoices it recognises. Three payments have no reference and wait for Monday.

The software shop imports the statement into bank reconciliation. Matches are suggested, confirmed in a few clicks, and only the three unclear payments need a phone call.

Month-end: the VAT period closes

The spreadsheet shop builds its VAT201 figures from totals, then spends an afternoon finding why output VAT does not agree with the invoices. The software shop runs its VAT report from the same lines that appear on each invoice, and the accountant files through SARS eFiling from figures that already agree. If you only need a quick check on one amount, the VAT calculator helps.

What the month cost each shop

Spreadsheet shopSoftware shop
Re-typing salesEvery invoice twiceOnce
Bank matchingHalf a dayUnder an hour
Lost work in outagesPossibleNone
VAT preparationAn afternoonA report
Knowing who owes whatRebuilt by handAlways current

Where the risk really sits

The time savings are pleasant, but the bigger reason to move is control. In a workbook, any cell can be overwritten and the figure simply changes. In software, the books are posted from invoices, bills and payments, so each figure traces back to the document that created it.

Lenders and investors also notice. Management accounts produced from a proper ledger, such as NaliSuite’s Accounting app, are easier to rely on than a spreadsheet only its author understands.

Getting paid faster

The software shop’s invoices carry a pay link. Customers pay by card or EFT through a provider such as PayFast, Ozow or Yoco connected to the shop’s own account, and the invoice marks itself paid. Details are on the online payments page.

Making the move

Most South African businesses switch at the start of a VAT period or a new tax year:

  1. Export customers, suppliers and stock from your workbook.
  2. Import them and capture opening balances and unpaid invoices.
  3. Keep both going for one VAT period if you want extra comfort.
  4. Close the period in the software and archive the spreadsheet.

Leaving Sage, Pastel or QuickBooks instead? The switching guide lists what to bring across.

A second example: a Cape Town catering business

A catering company in Cape Town quotes for weddings and corporate lunches, takes a deposit and invoices the balance after the event. The spreadsheet tracked deposits on one tab and final invoices on another, and every quarter a few deposits were never matched to their events.

In software, the quotation becomes the invoice, the deposit is recorded as a part payment and the final amount is what remains. Ingredient purchases are recorded against stock, so the owner can see gross profit by event instead of guessing.

A South African checklist for the switch

  • Start on the first day of a VAT period so the VAT201 for that period comes from one system.
  • Make sure every supplier’s VAT number is captured, so input VAT is supported.
  • Set up separate accounts for card settlement and EFT receipts, which arrive at different times.
  • Decide who on the team can approve supplier payments.
  • Keep the old workbook read-only for at least the period SARS may ask about.

Frequently asked questions

Will my accountant accept it?

Accountants generally prefer a proper double-entry ledger, and yours can be able to review and close the books with you in NaliSuite.

Does it work during load-shedding?

The books are online, so any device with mobile data can reach them.

Can it produce management accounts each month?

Yes. Profit and loss and the balance sheet come straight from the ledger.

Can I keep my existing bank account?

Yes. You keep banking where you do now and import the statements for reconciliation.

Try NaliSuite

Be the second print shop. NaliSuite plans start at R 38 a month and include accounting, invoicing and payroll, with a free trial to start. Compare plans.

Keep reading

Related articles

Start your website with Hostnali

Hosting, domains and 24/7 support from one team.